Well this is interesting. I'm never in favor of giving up boots-on-the-ground troops in favor of "cyber warfare" and "air and ground vehicle maintainers", that seems backwards to me. Yes I realize air and cyber are two areas the next war will likely be fought in, I'm SURE there is some less useful MOS that could be cut instead though.
The SMAW might be in need of replacement with something better, but I'm not sure this is the best call.
I bolded some stuff. Namely, how the commandant claims teaching an 0351 is no problem at all. Is that why the 0351 MOS required a higher ASVAB score? It seems like all of his points are much more fitting to the 0331 Machine Gunner MOS, since that's what pretty much everybody learned and did anyway. Since we didn't use the Mk19 a whole bunch, the 0331 MOS is really just for the 240 and .50 cal in most infantry companies? Train all the 0311's in machine guns and boom, there you go. Keep mortars and assaultmen separate.
I think his comments about combat engineers doing the SMAW and company demo are not realistic. We were always told we'd "get engineers" to do things, but they never appeared and we'd end up doing it anyway because things needed doing.
If anything, focus the 0351 on blowing shit up and breaching (not just doors, people forget about other obstacles and barricades) and give the rocket launchers wholesale to the Weapons Company. Then chop Weapons Company guys to the line companies for THAT capability.
0352 seemed more niche to me as well, or something that could easily be combined with 0351 like I'm told it was in the days of the Dragon launcher.
Lastly, if the Commandant actually does follow through and "align" an element of engineers with each company, are these going to be engineers that actually live with and train with the company? Or will they show up at Mojave Viper and then disappear again? Where are they going to come from, are there a bunch of engineers sitting around with nothing to do waiting to be re-tasked to help out an infantry company, so there will be no operation effects on THEIR mission once they start getting chopped up to infantry companies?
This is from Military.com, although Business Insider and others have published it as well:
Marine Corps to Cut Infantry Assaultman Job to Resource Other Roles
The Marine Corps is doing away with its 0351 infantry assaultman military occupational specialty and phasing out the assault section of Marine rifle companies in an effort to build up communities such as cyber and electronic warfare, Military.com has learned.
Commandant Gen. Robert Neller, who confirmed planning in December while on an annual tour of deployed Marine elements around the world, said he expects the move to happen in the next three to five years as part of a slate of changes designed to help the Corps prepare for future fights.
The 0351 infantry assaultman, one of the Marine Corps' five core infantry positions, is tasked with breaching, demolition, and rocket fire against fortified positions. Assaultmen carry the MK-153 shoulder-launched multipurpose assault weapon, or SMAW.
But Neller said he's making changes that will ensure those roles are filled by other members of a rifle company.
Each future rifle company will have an element of combat engineers aligned with it to take on breaching and demolition duties. The engineers will carry the SMAW, but they may not be the only ones.
"Can you shoot a SMAW?" Neller asked a Marine infantryman during a brief visit to elements of the Corps' crisis response task force for Africa in Moron, Spain.
The Marine responded that he could not.
"Yes, you can," Neller shot back. "I could teach you in five seconds."
Neller also confirmed that the Marine Corps plans to replace the SMAW in its breaching mission with the Carl Gustaf 84mm recoilless rifle, a possibility first reported exclusively by Military.com in November. That move will likely take place in the next four years.
"It's a little more sporty [than the SMAW], but it has 10 different kinds of ammunition," Neller said. " ... Do I like the SMAW? Yes, I do. But we had to give up something to get something else."
In an interview with Military.com, Neller explained that the plan to end the 0351 MOS and the assault section is a numbers game.
Marine Corps leaders made clear in early 2017 that they wanted a significant increase in end strength: 12,000 additional troops to resource fields such as cyber, information operations, and counter-drone efforts.
The service would add 3,000 Marines in 2017 and now expects an additional 1,000, thanks to the recently signed 2018 National Defense Authorization Act. But in the absence of a major plus-up, planners are looking for trade-offs.
"We had to create some trades to buy other Marines to do other things," Neller said.
At seven Marines in a company assault section, three companies in a battalion, and 24 battalions in the Marine Corps, the move will leave more than 500 spots available in the service to fill other jobs.
In addition to cyber, Neller said he's looking to build up intelligence analysis, air defense, and maintenance for ground vehicles and aviation.
It makes sense to cut the infantry assaultman MOS in part because it contains Marines of more junior ranks -- private to sergeant -- and its training overlaps with that of the other infantry MOSs, he said.
"The curriculum for 0311 [rifleman], 0331 [machine gunner], 0341 [mortarman], 0351 -- the first 28 days is exactly the same," Neller said. "So I don't think those Marines would have a whole lot of difficulty transitioning to another MOS."
Assaultmen who re-enlist have to transition to MOS 0369, platoon sergeant, anyway, he added.
If the Marine Corps eventually does get the larger plus-up it's after, Neller said, it could always bring the assault section back. Unlike more technologically sophisticated jobs such as cyber and electronic warfare that measure professional training in years, new assaultmen take a few months to train.
"It's part of the calculus on anything you do, is how hard is it to bring it back if you cadre it," Neller said.
Maximilian Uriarte, creator of the Terminal Lance webcomic that is hugely popular within the Marine Corps, has written in the past about his time as an infantry assaultman.
"It is kind of the oddball of the infantry; no one really knows what we do or how to properly employ us," he wrote in 2010. "As a result, we are often just turned into a rifle squad or divided to be machine gunners."
Uriarte told Military.com on Monday that rumors of the coming demise of the 0351 MOS had floated around the infantry for the entirety of his career.
Because of the specific, niche nature of the job, he said, 0351s end up doing other jobs on deployment. When he deployed to Iraq, he said, he ended up filling the always in-demand role of machine gunner.
"The whole idea of the job is to breach and blow open doors, and how often do you need to do that? Do you need a whole MOS for that?" he said.
But despite all that, Uriarte expressed nostalgia for the job.
"I am sad," he said. "I loved my MOS."